Why Cat Species that Purr do not Roar and Cat Species that Roar do not Purr


Cat owners love it when their cats purr, as it's generally taken to mean a sign of contentment - a happy cat.

Often the purr may be so low-pitched that you can only feel it when you are nursing the cat rather than hear it.

But how do cats do it and what is the real reason?

Can other members of the cat family purr? What about other animals as well?

Generally speaking members of the cat that can roar, such as tigers and lions can’t purr, while others that don't roar like mountain lions and bobcats do purr. It appears that the ability to roar requires changes in the structure of the vocal cords that prevents purring.

The other animals that can purr are civet, mongoose, genet, hyaenas, bears, badgers, guinea pigs, tapirs, elephants, rabbits, squirrels, ring-tailed lemurs, raccoons and even gorillas.

Cats purr when they are feeding their kittens. But why do cats purr? What other animals purr?
Cats purr when they are feeding their kittens. But why do cats purr? What other animals purr?
        Source: Stephanb [CC-BY-SA-3.0], via Wikimedia Commons
Domestic Cats purr but do not roar. The same applies to other animals. Why?
Domestic Cats purr but do not roar. The same applies to other animals. Why?
        Source: Mueller-rech.muenchen (Own work) [CC-BY-SA-3.0], via Wikimedia Commons



How do Cats Purr?

There have been a number of theories advanced by purr experts of the years, but the jury is out snoring. This is the latest advice:

Cats purr when they are asleep. But they stop when they hear the sound of running water. Why?
Cats purr when they are asleep. But they stop when they hear the sound of running water. Why?
Source: Andrew [Public Domain], via Wikimedia Commons
Cats purr when they lick their paws. Gorillas and many large animals purr - imagine that!
Cats purr when they lick their paws. Gorillas and many large animals purr - imagine that!
Source: By tracy from North Brookfield, Massachusetts [CC-BY-2.0], via Wikimedia Commons

Why Do Cats Purr?

Purring may have developed to keep the family group together. While cats purr when contented, they also purr when they are scared or threatened. In a way the cat purr may be equivalent to a human smile. People sometimes smile when they are nervous or concerned as well as when they are content and happy pussies.

Scientists who are devoted to purring and spend most of their lives listening, recording and analysing purrs have found some interesting results. It appears that cats add a special vocalization to their purrs to solicit a response from humans nearby. Some cats add parts of a cry-meow, a higher frequency sound to their normal purrs. It appears that this is designed to please humans so they will feed them sooner.

Cats also purr when they are in pain from injuries. Mother cats often purr during labor. Some cats purr when they are near death. Kittens purr very soon after being born and the ability appears to be innate.

How Do Humans React to Cat Purrs?

Humans generally react positively to purrs and see it as a sign that the cat is calm, happy and at peace. It also acts as a reinforcement that what the human is doing is right and the cat likes it. Cats know this and make use of purrs to manipulate humans.

The original purpose of purrs may have been to enable a kitten to let their mother know that "all is well." Kittens can purr and nurse at the same time. The mother cat often purrs back and this may reassure the kitten that all is well.

Vets hate it when cats purr because this makes it almost impossible for the vet to hear the cat's heart or air moving in their lungs.

One odd thing to try is that many cats will stop purring when they hear the sound of running water. Some vets use this trick to dampen the purring so they can examine the cat.

Try this trick with your cat. See if it works for you.